Kase Learning Short Selling Conference Presentations 2018

Whitney Tilson recently launched a new investment conference focused on short selling called the Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.  They've released some videos of pitches from the presentations and we've aggregated them here along with notes from each talk if you just want a quick summary.

Click each link below to go to the presentation.


Kase Learning Short Selling Conference Presentations 2018

- Sahm Adrangi (Kerrisdale Capital): On ad fraud and Quinstreet (QNST)

- Mark Spiegel (Stanphyl Capital): Short Tesla (TSLA)

- Gabriel Grego (Quintessential Capital): Short Folli Follie

- Jillian McIntyre (221B Capital): Short Intelsat (I)

- Berna Barshay (Viola Capital): Short Ralph Lauren (RL)

- Enrique Abeyta: Short Anheuser Busch InBev (BUD)

- Chris Brown (Aristides Capital): Short Energous (WATT)

- Asher Jacobs & Jade Hu (Columbia MBAs): Short Stericycle (SRCL)

Mark Spiegel Short Tesla Presentation: Kase Learning Conference

We're posting up a series of presentations from the recent Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.  Next up is Mark Spiegel who pitched short Tesla (TSLA).  He thinks the company is a zero.


Mark Spiegel's Presentation: Short Tesla (TSLA)

- Telsa's financials are horrible and has no moat of any kind, and this is all before a ton of competition comes online

- Management can't be trusted after Elon Musk made misleading statements

- Lost over $25,000 per car sold based on recent earnings.  Sales of two top models were down double digits year-over-year, again this is before top competition comes online from Porsche, Jaguar and others

- $2.3 billion in negative net working capital, And - $1bn in negative net working capital.  Bulls point to the story being about 'the future' but Tesla's tax credits will expire later this year while competitors will just be starting to use their credits.

- Competition coming:  Jaguar I-Pace coming out is $10,000 less and much nicer.  Jaguar XJ Sedan also going electric.  Audi electric SUV coming 2018 winter and priced $5000 cheaper once Tesla's tax credit runs out.  Porsche's Mission E sedan coming.  Mercedes' ECQ coming out and electric version of the S Class.  Hyundai coming out with a crossover for the mass market.  Chevrolet Bolt out now.  Nissan Leaf next year increases electric range.  First electric Volvo comes out next year.  BMW iX3 comes out in 2 years, and i4 flagship electric car.  The list goes on and on.

-  China is a big market and very important; bulls think TSLA will gain share there but the reality is that so much competition is coming especially in that country that they've already lost

-  Other car companies using larger battery cells and Tesla is committed to smaller, inferior ones

-  Stunning number of executive departures.  Jim Chanos said the only two companies that had similar numbers are Enron and Valeant

Embedded below is the video of Mark Spiegel's presentation:




Be sure to check out the rest of the presentations from the Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.

Sahm Adrangi's Presentation on Ad Fraud & Short QuinStreet: Kase Learning Short Selling Conference

We're posting up a series of presentations from the recent Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.  Next up is Sahm Adrangi of Kerrisdale Capital who presented about ad fraud and talked about Quinstreet (QNST) which he published a short report on last month.


Sahm Adrangi's Presentation on Ad Fraud & Short QuinStreet (QNST)

- Recently gave a presentation on being short St. Joe (JOE) and short QuinStreet (presentation here), the latter of which plays into the theme of ad fraud

- Ad fraud is basically when online ad impressions or clicks are artificially higher due to bots, not actual users viewing the material.  Pay-per-click ads see 'fake' clicks and then there's sites with tons of fake traffic that are just full of ads to inflate the numbers.  Ad stuffing is when a video has other videos behind the main video someone is watching, giving impressions to something that's not actually being viewed

- Ad fraud is so prevalent and the intermediaries are beneficiaries of it (ad agencies etc), making them slow to adopt preventive measures.  The ultimate loser is the buyer of the ad but it's difficult to detect who is viewing your ad (human vs bot)

-  Technology is rapidly evolving and the bad actors are using more sophisticated measures to generate more fraud

- QuinStreet: if you look at investor presentations or management comments, it's hard to discern where exactly the revenue is coming from (lead generation, or ad-matching placements, etc).   Another report by a separate firm attacked Criteo late last year for suspect traffic as well.

- Walked through examples where some of Quinstreet's sites were receiving traffic from other sites that isn't what it seems: a car insurance site was receiving a lot of traffic, but not from people looking for quotes on car insurance, but rather people earning 'swag bucks' for filling out online surveys and things like that.  Thus car insurers buying ads / paying for leads, weren't really getting what they thought they were (the video below walks through the whole scenario as it's too long to type out)

- Thinks the opacity in the online ad space and lack of disclosures is a good place for short activists to hunt

Embedded below is the video of Sahm Adrangi's presentation:



mbedded below is the slideshow pdf of Sahm Adrangi & Kerrisale Capital's presentation on short QuinStreet (QNST):



Be sure to check out the rest of the presentations from the Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.

Jillian McIntyre's Short Intelsat Presentation: Kase Learning Conference

We're posting up a series of presentations from the recent Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.  Next up is Jillian McIntyre of 221B Capital who pitched a short of Intelsat (I).  She runs a fundamental long/short equity fund, typically running 20% net short, typically focuses companies with poor corporate governance (Germany, UK, South Africa, Australia).  Previously worked with Sir Chris Hohn's TCI Fund.


Jillian McIntyre's Presentation: Short Intelsat

- 50% downside in her opinion, only 7% short interest.  $14bn of debt, $1bn run-rate of interest every year, negative cashflow

- Believes company is ripe for technology disruption and has a bad business model; needs capital ASAP

- Company is in satellite communications, provides signal broadcast to major networks, media companies etc.  Mainly exposure to Latin America and Africa.  Thinks there's some similarities to SunEdison (which they pitched back in 2015 which went bankrupt): levels of indebtedness & bad business model

- The recent hype surrounding 5G and the big spectrum auction in November has led to irrational exuberance as Intelsat is up almost 300% this year.  Lot of hype around the potential for C band spectrum.  Even if it's allowed by FCC, could take over a year to start to monetize it.  She thinks the company will see disruption in its ancient satellite model.  Lower-orbit satellites will be launched and are better and cheaper than Intelsat's much higher satellites.  Lots of hype also around potential with 'OneWeb'

-  Co has very complex debt structure and is a serial re-structurer: they think it breached covenants and will need to raise $400-500 million and worst case $1.5-2 bn. Don't think they have access to new revolving credit facilities.  Thinks they have aggressive accounting regarding bad debt provision and amortization rates and reliance on future revenue


Embedded below is the video of Jillian McIntyre's presentation:





Be sure to check out the rest of the presentations from the Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.

Berna Barshay Short Ralph Lauren Presentation: Kase Learning Conference

We're posting up a series of presentations from the recent Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.  Next up is Berna Barshay of Viola Capital Management who pitched a short of Ralph Lauren (RL). 


Berna Barshay's Presentation: Short Ralph Lauren (RL)

-  Consumer specialist.  Industry ripe with disruption.

-  80% of household purchase decisions made by women, 80% of investment choices made by men

-  Ralph Lauren in the middle of attempted turnaround:  Co has lost 19% of sales last three years.  Why?  Historically positioned as an upscale brand, they over distributed (discounting, margin pressure).  Longtime COO departure led to disruption.  Trying to now pullback on promotions and try to reach a new, younger customer.  Stock up 70% in last 9 months, she's more skeptical on turnaround attempt and speed at which it would happen.

-  In the age of Instagram, brands can't control their story as much.  RL is too focused on North America.  Department stores in secular decline.  Trying to replicate Coach merely by reducing points of distribution

-  Ratio of outlets to full price stores is out of whack and is a challenge to elevating the brand back up.  Co is also omnipresent in the 'off price' channel.  TJMaxx and Marshall has a lot of inventory and continued to grow.  The difference between the $89 polo shirt at their flagship store wasn't that much different from the $35 polo shirt at TJMaxx.  RL has devalued their signature item and devalued their brand in the process.  This will be a headwind in the brand elevation efforts.

-  Co wants to update the product and modernize the brand: does this alienate the core customer they have?  Tough to straddle.  It's a preppy, country club look that's been around since the 70s.  Millennials and younger have much different street style

-  She talked to 200 Millennials about favorite clothing brands and received a wide array of responses: RL hardly on the radar, lots of newer brands, niche brands, etc.  Barriers to entry in clothing have come way down.  RL did much better with men than women in survey.

-  Near-term return to topline growth is nearly impossible due to off-price channel and department stores in secular decline.  Trading at 18x like a luxury goods stock but needs to show tangible results

-  Brand turnaround takes years and thinks that while expectations are low, still thinks estimates are too high.  Upcoming investor day could be a catalyst.  Thinks earnings will be flattish for next 2 years.  N. America growth will be down 4%, 11% earnings miss.  Thinks it should trade around 13x, for 30% downside though it's not a valuation short 

Embedded below is the video of Berna Barshay's presentation:




Be sure to check out the rest of the presentations from the Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.

Gabriel Grego's Short Folli Follie Presentation: Kase Learning Conference

We're posting up a series of presentations from the recent Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.  Next up is Gabriel Grego of Quintessential Capital who pitched a short of Folli Follie.  (Please note that since presenting earlier this month, the stock traded down 70% and was subsequently halted.)


Gabriel Grego's Presentation: Short Folli Follie

-  Co has 1.3bn euros of sales, trades on the Greek exchange, products are watches, purses, mainly jewelry etc.  70% of revenue and all profit originates in Asia, mainly China.  Now investing into the United States

- Actual sales and profitability are less than accounting suggests. Business is shrinking rapidly, they are worried about potential insolvency

-  Called 630 stores, they only found 289 open... nobody answered or store was closed.  Out of 248 supposed stores in Asia, they only found 64.  Hired Chinese and Japanese teams to do due diligence in the countries.  Went to visit stores, found many were tiny, non-existent or liquidating

-  Claims solid online sales, but traffic is tiny compared to big competitors who supposedly generate similar revenues.  Social media has a tiny presence as well compared to others

-  Thinks the company will have to issue shares or bonds to makeup for a shortfall soon

-  Company claims $1 billion of sales in Asia, but actual China subsidiaries are only showing millions of dollars.  Company has always used the same auditor then suddenly switched to another auditor that's not really as well known

Embedded below is the video of Gabriel Grego's presentation:




Be sure to check out the rest of the presentations from the Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.

Enrique Abeyta Short Anheuser Busch Inbev Presentation: Kase Learning Conference

We're posting up a series of presentations from the recent Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.  Next up is Enrique Abeyta who pitched a short of Anheuser Busch Inbev (BUD).  

Enrique Abeyta's Presentation: Short Anheuser Busch Inbev (BUD)

-  Thinks there will be negative earnings revisions.  Craft brewers are a threat, but contract brewing and the lower hurdle to entry in the market is the bigger story: it costs very little to start up a tiny beer somewhere and start producing.

-While most legacy beer companies built their advantage via scale and advertising via expensive mediums (TV, print) today advertising costs have come way down via online advertising and you can target the exact type of customer you're looking for.

-  Also thinks Kraft Heinz (KHC) and Disney (DIS) will face similar threats and would be short those as well (KHC: lots of micro brands starting ot popup, DIS: cost of producing content is coming down and others can do so much more cheaply)

Below is the video of Enrique Abeyta's pitch on shorting Budweiser:





Be sure to check out the rest of the presentations from the Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.

Chris Brown Short Energous (WATT): Kase Learning Conference

We're posting up a series of presentations from the recent Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.  Next up is Chris Brown of Aristides Capital who pitched short Energous (WATT).


Chris Brown's Presentation: Short Energous (WATT)

- Company's stock skyrocketed late last year on FCC approval news.  Says CEO pretty much always lies. 

- Energous has an agreement with Apple

- Company seeking to do RF or wireless charging at a distance: claims to create pockets of energy around your device to charge it. The physics behind it isn't new and technology isn't new.  The science behind it is explained in the video below but basically what they're trying to do isn't practical and is extremely exagerrated

- Lots of insider sales recently

-  Marketing is touting 'vaporware' and doing a good job of hyping things.  He thinks the company is a zero and a fraud.


Embedded below is the video of Chris Brown's presentation:





Be sure to check out the rest of the presentations from the Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.

Asher Jacobs & Jade Hu Short Stericycle (SRCL) Presentation: Kase Learning Conference

We're posting up a series of presentations from the recent Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.  Next up is Asher Jacbos and Jade Hu, Columbia MBA students who pitched a short of Stericycle (SRCL).


Asher Jacbos & Jade Hu's Presentation: Short Stericycle (SRCL)

-  See 36% downside over the next 18 months.  Fallout over recent lawsuit settlement is only in the early innings as it highlighted the company's price gouging.  Company won't be able to continue its rollup strategy with 4 turns of leverage.  Numerous accounting redflags highlight the company's deteriorating fundamentals

-  Company focuses on the medical waste market with around 80% market share.  Has expanded to other industries like shredding, environmental waste, and other areas

-  They expect the company's pricing power increases to be capped at around 5%, compared to historic increases of 18% biannually.  Competition will increase in the space as they're heavily spending on marketing to take share

-  Think one segment's revenue will drop 7% based on lack of ability to drive pricing.  Sees volume decreasing 7% (but not as severe as it was previously) as they're making price concessions to drive business.  7% revenue decline leads to a 14% EBITDA decrease

-  Company is seeing a mix shift to lower margin businesses.  Credit rating was recently downgraded, lots of debt due in 2020

-  Thinks management is focused on empire building, as incentive compensation is built on absolute adjusted EBITDA

- Expect continued earnings misses, large asset impairment.  Base case assumes 9x EV/EBITDA.  If margins stabilize and the stock gets a higher multiple, there's only 20% upside, capping risk on the short


Embedded below is the video of their presentation:



And here's a link to their presentation from the Columbia Business School's Graham & Doddsville newsletter.

Be sure to check out the rest of the presentations from the Kase Learning Short Selling Conference.